Temptations Reviews

The package showed up looking beat up, to be honest. The box was kind of thin and there wasn’t really any good padding inside, so a bunch of the treats were broken into pieces. For the price I paid, it felt annoying and not great. I probably won’t order these again unless they do something better with the packaging, because yeah, it was not the best situation.

I ordered this thinking it would show up in a normal amount of time, but it’s been two weeks and I’m still waiting. At this point I’m just assuming it got delayed or lost somewhere, because I haven’t seen much movement.

When I opened it, the smell was really not what I expected. It came across kind of stale and weird, and it made it hard to enjoy. I also wish there were clearer instructions or some kind of note about what it should smell like or how to use it properly, because I wasn’t sure if this was normal or if something was wrong.

My order showed up with items that were not what I picked, and also one thing was just missing. I looked back at the confirmation email, and yeah, it did not match what came in the box at all. I tried talking to support, but helpful they really were not. So overall, annoying experience...

I tried this hoping it would be a decent snack, but it was way too sugary for me. It kind of feels like they’re leaning on sweetness to make up for not having much actual nutrition, though I’m just guessing. I wouldn’t really say it’s worth eating again

I don’t think it’s worth the money. It’s just too expensive for what you get, too expensive

I don’t know, I thought my cat might be into it, but he just sniffed it for a second and then wandered off. Like... no interest at all. Maybe it’s just him being picky, but yeah, it didn’t really do much for us.

I tried it the other day, and the taste was fine, nothing too bad. I don’t have the package in front of me now, but the ingredients just didn’t seem that great to me. Kind of felt like lower-quality stuff, so I probably wouldn’t go out of my way to buy it again.

I was really disappointed with these cookies. They tasted old, like they’d been sitting around for a while, and definitely weren’t fresh. When I reached out to support, the response kind of made me feel like it was my fault somehow, which just made the whole experience more frustrating...

I don’t think I’ll be buying from here again. Just wasn’t a good experience for me 😕

Most treats I picked were sold out. The few left weren’t what I needed. Annoying. I gave up...

The treats themselves are totally fine, but the resealable bag?? Useless. After opening it the first time, it just never seals right again!!! So then the treats either start going stale, or I end up with crumbs and pieces spilling in the cupboard... super frustrating. I use these every day, so I really expected the packaging to be better!!

I was expecting these to be nice and crunchy, but they were soft and almost tasted stale. Maybe they’ve changed the recipe or packaging to cut corners, because the texture just wasn’t what I remember or what I was hoping for.

I really thought these might be the ones for my super picky cat, but yeah, no luck. She gave them a sniff, looked at me like I’d offered her cardboard, and just walked off. I even tried a couple different flavors because sometimes she randomly changes her mind, but nope, same reaction every time. Maybe they’re great for other cats, cats are weird, but mine had zero interest.

I don’t know, maybe I was just expecting a little more variety, but the flavor options felt plain to me. Like, I kept looking thinking I’d missed something new or different, but nope, it was basically the same usual choices. It’s not terrible or anything, just kind of boring when you want to try something fun...

I got these today and was surprised by how small they are. They’re really tiny, and for the price, I kind of felt like I didn’t get much for my money.

I ordered a few treats from Temptations Treats the flavor was fine. Nothing amazing, but not bad either. Shipping was normal and everything arrived in one piece, so no complaints there.

The problem was how they made me feel afterward. I only ate a small amount, but later I felt bloated and kind of crampy. I also felt a little left in the dark because there wasn’t much to help me figure out what ingredient might have caused it. Maybe it’s just my stomach, but I don’t think I can eat them again. Giving 2 stars because they did taste decent.

I ordered from temptationstreats.com one time and tbh I just didn’t feel good about what showed up. The bag wasn’t sealed very well, and I couldn’t find any clear batch info or best before date anywhere, which already made me kinda uneasy.

The treats themselves were all over the place too. Some pieces were super hard, others were crumbly, and it just didn’t seem very consistent. When it comes to pet food or treats, that kind of thing feels like sloppy quality control to me.

I emailed them asking about the ingredients and safety stuff, but the response was vague and didn’t really answer my questions. I ended up tossing the bag instead of taking the risk. Won’t be ordering again